Carelli's Pizzeria Pasta - Craig, Colorado

Kayla Wewer

Awesome casual dining, perfectly crispy crusted pizza and the pasta was also delicious! Very happy we went here. The “widowmaker” is a personal favorite!

Devin Jurgensen

Hadn’t made it at all in since the new owners bought it. Finally tried it today. The Stromboli was amazing! There was a lot of food, and it was really good. The quality of ingredients was excellent, not a lot of grease from the meats, the cheese was abundant and melty. Definitely recommend!!

Charae Flores

Carelli’s Pizzeria a quiet little fancy restaurant in the small town of Craig. This place is absolutely divine. The atmosphere was comfy, warm, sweet, and relaxing. The service was fantastic, kind, fast and sweet. I went with my family of 7. We got a table immediately, served drinks, an our appetizers were taken and brought back so conveniently. We had 3 children with us and their kids menu was very helpful for making lunch decisions. Every plate brought to the table was Delicious. I couldn’t believe the taste and satisfying feeling I got from my meal. The babies an us adults had enough to eat and extra to take home after. In all the experience was wonderful. My partner and I also do take out order of their Pizzas her All the time. We really enjoy them. The Pizza is Crispy, Juices, Flavorful and has the right temperature for a perfect bite. Carelli’s has a great menu to choose from. So if your around Craig, Colorado and want a Fancy Pizza and Italian Flavor Dining experience, or a Take Out with family and friends or alone come on by.

Christ Endeavors Ministry

All I can say is WOW!!! The Pizza I've always been searching for!!! If you want authentic New York Pizza look no further, the owners are incredible warm folks who are a joy to visit with and know their stuff about pie!!! The dough is exquisite with the perfect chew and a flavor that stands alone, and the sauce is subtle but delicious and marries the whole pie together in a perfect harmony. World Class Pizza! Craig Colorado you got a Great One!!!

Michael McGlade

If you’re looking for good pizza in Craig, CO you have to go to Carelli’s. They make excellent NY style pizza. I was skeptical at first looking for good pizza during our stay in Craig and was pleasantly surprised by just how good the pizza was. Some of the best that I’ve ever had! The owners are super friendly and we had a fun time chatting with them while we were waiting for our take out.

Kathy Sutherland

We ordered at the counter from a chalkboard on the wall. We were offered other dishes that were not on the board, too. We were told to order, get our own drinks, and have a seat. Our food was delivered to our table. We went to the counter to pay. 4 adults, a 6 yo and 8 yo was $150.
When we realized there were no prices listed we became a little concerned. The pizza & stromboli were amazing! The place was really cute. We saw a lot of pizza take outs while we were there.
We would definitely order pizza again if we lived in Craig!

Justin Smith

Not what it used to be only opened on weekends. New owners. Greasy pizza it's sad really. It used to be a cool place with dollars on the ceiling and it's own Colorado pizza vibe. Now it's a sad shell of what it was. It gives off a senior citizen Pizza vibe.

Carl Straessle

Awesome Meatball Sub!!!

The pizza crust is perfect! The crust is thin, crispy and tastes great!

Tony makes this place feel like a real NY pizza joint!

I will eat here again.