All Star Pizzeria - Fountain, CO

Diana EG

These wings were $20. That included $4 just because they are bone-in. Plus and extra charge for using a card to pay and extra charge for getting ranch with them. $60 for a pizza and these wings. They don’t even look cooked; hardly any sauce. $20 dollar wings. Also, their website says they give military discount but at time of pickup, was told no military discount. You decide if you want to take your chances going there.

Rebecca Miller “Becky”

The place is a perfect little hole in the wall!! The cheesy bread, oof, fantastic!! ?
I got a 10" meat lovers pizza with 1 topping swap substitution and a bottle of soda, and it was about 20$. The crust isn't too thick, and the flavor was delightful and so savory!! If you're ever in the area, highly recommend!!

x x “MagicNinjaX”

All the recent 1-star reviews echo the truth. Chris's managerial skills are severely lacking, and the quality of this establishment has plummeted in recent months. My longstanding loyalty as a customer has been shattered, and I've decided to never order pizza again. This experience stands as the epitome of the worst management and service I've ever encountered. It's disheartening to see this place falter so drastically.

Save both your time and hard-earned money by avoiding this establishment. Their conduct is truly shameful. If you peruse my other reviews, you'll gain insight into the extent of the disappointment my family and I faced. Their website and online ordering system are riddled with glitches, and unbelievably, they penalize customers for using it.

The range of superior alternatives in the vicinity offers hassle-free online ordering without the unnecessary drama. If you relish the idea of having your order unceremoniously canceled, being guilt-tripped over items you rightfully ordered, encountering geographic constraints despite placing an online order, overpaying, or missing items that never get refunded then by all means, this establishment fits the bill.

Should you encounter any issues, prepare yourself to be condescended to, treated as if you lack intelligence, and promptly dismissed by the manager who supposedly values your business. If you're in the market for an establishment that offers such an experience, then I wholeheartedly endorse this laughable excuse for a business.

bryan guilen

I thought this place was excellent the only reason I gave it four stars was because I did a delivery and I got no Ranch for my wings no marinara sauce for my breadsticks and no napkins. But I would definitely order from this place again

Logan Puente

I wish I lived in fountain so I could come here more often, $8.99 pickup special for a whole large pizza is an incredible deal and the pizza was amazing. I nice even layer of corn meal on the bottom, a crisp outside and well developed soft gluten structure inside, it was amazing. I’m tempted to drive back for more haha

AJ Craycraft

Pizza was very mid, doughy, 3/10, basically cafeteria pizza. Wings and mozzarella sticks in the same boat basically cafeteria food. The cheese bread was the only thing worth buying. Also website says they offer a military discount however in store was told that’s not a thing they do.

Paul Stromberg

Absolutely awesome!!! We passed through town and stopped for lunch. Got stuffed mushrooms, breadsticks, and the pickle ranch pizza. It was all very, very good!! We only have touristy restaurants in our Colorado town, so this was a welcome and amazing change! I highly recommend stopping here if you want great food at a reasonable price!! Well done, All Star!!!

Afterthought edit…I moved here from Chicago and have been telling my friends that Colorado pizza sucks. Nope. I have found truly excellent Colorado pizza!!!

Toby Gerchcovich “Black Condor”

It's our favorite local joint. Good pizza, keeps well, is good cold, feeezes and reheats properly, fresh ingredients. Dough is really good. Prices are very decent compared to chains.